Never Miss Another Deal!

No Fuss Deal Surprise Me

Oster Retro 2-Slice Toaster Review: Good Looks and Even Toast, Once It Settles In

The Oster 2 Slice Toaster is a good-looking toaster that toasts evenly once settled, best for bagel eaters. Rated 4.2 out of 5 across 722 user ratings. The main drawback: slow with frozen bread compared with older Oster toasters. We scored it 4.1 out of 5.

By Whimsical Pris, Kitchen Editor Published December 17, 2025 Updated September 26, 2026
4.1Our score
Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 2 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 3 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 4 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 5 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 6 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 7 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 8 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 9 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 10 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 11 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 12 Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check Lever, Extra-Wide Slots, Impressions Collection, Blue, view 13
Product gallery, 13 images
$85.67 Check price on Amazon

Prices shown were correct on September 26, 2026 and change frequently.

TL;DRThe Short Answer: Is the Oster 2 Slice Toaster Worth It?

A toaster bought for its looks still has to brown bread properly, and this one does, though not always straight out of the box and not necessarily for years. Oster's retro blue two-slicer brings wide slots, seven shade settings and a quick-check lever for peeking at toast mid-cycle, and once it settles in it browns evenly. The catch is staying power: early batches can be patchy, and durability is its weakest point, with some units failing after about four months.

NoFussDeal rates the Oster 2 Slice Toaster 4.1 out of 5 at $85.67. Last updated September 26, 2026.

Key Facts

Product Dimensions
8.8"D x 8.2"W x 13"H
Wattage
900 watts
Voltage
220 volts
Material
Stainless Steel
Color
Blue
Special Features
Cancel Function

What Stands Out

  1. Quick-check lever lets you look at the toast mid-cycle without interrupting it
  2. Extra-wide slots for a wide variety of breads and bagels
  3. 7 toast shade settings, plus Bagel and Frozen functions that adjust toasting time
  4. Cancel option stops toasting at the press of a button
  5. 900 watts, two slots, and a removable crumb tray
  6. Textured blue Impressions Collection finish with chrome accents that gives the counter a retro look

Strengths and Drawbacks

What works

  • Even browning once settled in, and bagels come out very even
  • Quick-check lever lets you look at the toast without interrupting the cycle
  • 7 shade settings with a wide range, from barely crisp to just shy of burnt
  • Bagel function browns the cut face and leaves the outside soft
  • Extra-wide slots and a toast lift lever make bread easy to remove
  • Textured blue finish with chrome accents gives it real retro appeal
  • Removable crumb tray for cleaning

What does not

  • Can toast unevenly at first and may need about 20 uses to settle in
  • Slow with frozen bread compared with older Oster toasters, despite the quick-heating claim
  • No end-of-cycle bell, so you have to keep an eye on it
  • The arrow on the shade control is too tiny to read easily
  • Durability is the weak point: some units fail within months, and the body feels lightweight
  • Two slots only, and no published slot width for thick slices

Features in Depth

01

Quick-Check Lever and Toast Lift Lever

Toast Shade Settings 7 Special Features Cancel Function Early Consistency Improves after break-in

The signature feature is the Quick-Check lever: lift it partway during a cycle to see how the toast is browning without ending the cycle. On most toasters, checking means popping the carriage, which stops the timer, and pushing it back down starts a fresh cycle that can overshoot. Here a peek costs nothing. A separate toast lift lever raises finished toast so it is easy to take out without fishing around near the hot slots. Results aren't always perfect from day one, though. A new unit can toast unevenly for its first couple of dozen cycles before it settles, so expect to spend a few breakfasts dialling it in.

$85.67 4.1/5 Check price
02

Extra-Wide Slots and 900-Watt Heating

Wattage 900 watts Slot Count 2 Product Dimensions 8.8"D x 8.2"W x 13"H

Extra-wide slots and a 900-watt element are aimed at more than standard sandwich bread: bagels and a wide variety of breads go in without getting pinched, and they are easy to lift out without burnt fingers. At 8.8 inches deep, 8.2 inches wide and 13 inches tall it takes up little counter width for a two-slicer, though check the height if it has to sit under a cabinet. Seven shade settings give plenty of range, from barely crisp at the lowest to just shy of burnt a little past halfway, a wide usable band for bagels. Evenness isn't guaranteed for every unit straight out of the box, so expect to spend a little time finding your setting.

$85.67 4.1/5 Check price
03

Bagel, Frozen and Cancel Functions

Number of Programs 7 Display Type LED Evenness Good once settled

Beyond the shade dial there are three function buttons. Bagel lengthens the cycle and browns the cut face while leaving the outside soft, so the bagel has to go in the right way round. Frozen extends the heating time for bread straight from the freezer, which is what stops a frozen slice coming out crisp outside and cold in the middle. Cancel stops the cycle immediately; it replaces the old habit of pulling the lever up to stop, which takes a little getting used to. Oster specifies 7 programs and an LED display, but the arrow on the shade control is so small it can be hard to read at a glance. The buttons give you more ways to dial in results than a no-frills toaster, but they don't change how evenly a particular unit browns.

$85.67 4.1/5 Check price
04

Impressions Collection Design, Crumb Tray, and Durability

Appearance Retro, widely liked Durability Weak point Value for Money Fair for the looks

The Impressions Collection is Oster's retro-styled line, built in stainless steel with chrome accents and a textured finish, here in blue. The vintage look is the part almost nobody quibbles with, although the exact shade is worth checking closely, since colour is a matter of taste. A removable crumb tray slides out from underneath for cleanup. Longevity is the concern. Durability is the weakest part of the package: some units have stopped working after roughly four months, and the body feels a little light. The retro styling doesn't necessarily come with build quality to match, so if you want a toaster that lasts many years, weigh that against the looks and buy somewhere with an easy return policy.

$85.67 4.1/5 Check price

How We Scored It

Based on
The manufacturer's published specifications and the product's live Amazon listing.
Owner rating
4.2 out of 5 on Amazon, recorded September 26, 2026
How we score
We score each thing that comes up most in owner feedback on the Oster® Retro 2-Slice Toaster with Quick-Check. Seven things come up most in owner feedback: one draws praise, five split opinion and one draws mostly complaints. Its ratings average 4.2 stars (66% five stars, 15% four, 8% three and 11% one or two), so every score starts at 84, that average on a 100 point scale. Where opinion is split, we take off 6. Where it draws mostly complaints, we take off 12. Then we read eight owner reviews in full (every one we found gave it four or five stars) and move the score up to 5 points either way depending on how the owners who mention it rated the product. Our overall score starts from the same 4.2 star average and loses 0.1 for each thing that draws mostly complaints, with 0.1 more when at least a tenth of ratings are one star, never more than 0.3 in all. Here that takes off 0.1, which gives 4.1. Read our editorial standards

Appearance

The toaster's vintage appearance stands out. Oster lists the color as Blue and the material as Stainless Steel. Two of the eight owner reviews we read mention it. All of them gave the product four or five stars. Score 89: we started at 84 and added 5 because the owner reviews that mention it are positive.

89Positive

Quality

None of the eight owner reviews we read mention it. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opinion is split.

78Mixed

Functionality

Two of the eight owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opini…

Read the full note (412 characters)

Two of the eight owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opinion is split.

78Mixed

Toasts Evenly

Seven of the eight owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opi…

Read the full note (414 characters)

Seven of the eight owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opinion is split.

78Mixed

Color

Oster lists the color as Blue. One of the eight owner reviews we read mentions it, and that owner gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 8…

Read the full note (442 characters)

Oster lists the color as Blue. One of the eight owner reviews we read mentions it, and that owner gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opinion is split.

78Mixed

Durability

None of the eight owner reviews we read mention it. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 72: we started at 84 and took off 12 because it draws mostly complaints.

72Needs Improvement

Owner Satisfaction

66% of ratings are five stars and 15% are four. 8% are three stars and 11% are one or two. The spread skews positive, but enough ratings sit low that the drawbacks below are worth reading. Score 84: its 4.2 star average on a 100 point scale.

84Mostly Positive

Value for Money

Two of the eight owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opini…

Read the full note (412 characters)

Two of the eight owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 19% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 78: we started at 84 and took off 6 because opinion is split.

78Mixed

Specifications

Size and weight

Product Dimensions
8.8"D x 8.2"W x 13"H

Power

Wattage
900 watts
Voltage
220 volts

Materials and warranty

Material
Stainless Steel
Color
Blue

Other specifications

Special Features
Cancel Function

What Buyers Say

Based on 722 Amazon customer ratings, averaging 4.2 out of 5, recorded 12 September 2026. See the reviews on Amazon

5 stars 66%
4 stars 15%
3 stars 8%
2 stars 4%
1 stars 7%
★★★★★

Bagels.

All I want in life is some well toasted bagels. This toaster delivers. Perfectly even, nice amount of toast just shy of burnt at a smidge past halfway on the dial. Cutting the dial back to 1… Read it on Amazon
M.L. Syd · Jan 26, 2022
★★★★★

Adorable and works well

I use this every morning to toast bread straight out of the freezer. I use setting 6 and the bread comes out lightly toasted. It does take longer to toast the bread than my previous Oster to… Read it on Amazon
Ariel D. · Nov 04, 2023
★★★★☆

Where's the bell? ;-)

This is a nice toaster that does a good job on bread, English muffins, etc. I like the button that extends the cook time for bagels. I'm used to simply pulling up on the lever to interrupt a… Read it on Amazon
S. C. OBrien · Jul 20, 2022
★★★★★

It TOASTS like TOAST is supposed to be TOASTED!

♥️ This toaster. Not only does it look good but i had forgotten HOW properly toasted toast should taste.If i must have anything negative to say it may be the little browning control button. … Read it on Amazon
ANKAN1 · Feb 05, 2025
★★★★★

Case stays cool, needs burn-in time

Im very happy with the unit now but not initially. It needed burn in time. At first it did not toast evenly. I would have returned it but my husband liked the unit. After maybe 20 uses the t… Read it on Amazon
T. in Texas · Apr 19, 2022
★★★★★

Nice toaster!

Nice red, works well
andrea k. · Feb 17, 2025

Setting It Up

  1. Unbox and place on the counter

    The box contains one toaster. It measures 8.8 in deep, 8.2 in wide and 13 in high, so check the height against any overhead cabinets.

  2. Check the crumb tray

    Make sure the removable crumb tray is seated in place before the first use.

  3. Choose a shade setting

    Pick one of the 7 settings. Setting 1 just barely crisps bread and a little past halfway is close to burnt, so start in the middle; frozen bread needs a higher setting, around 6.

  4. Load the slots, checking bagel direction

    Place bread or bagels in the two extra-wide slots. With the Bagel function the cut side has to face a particular way, so check the instructions before the first bagel.

  5. Select Bagel or Frozen if needed

    The Bagel and Frozen functions automatically adjust toasting time for those foods.

  6. Give the first batches some leeway

    A new unit may not toast evenly at first. It tends to settle in after a couple of dozen uses, so don't judge it on the first few batches.

Common Questions

Does the Quick-Check lever really let you check toast without restarting the cycle?

Yes. Lifting the Quick-Check lever shows you how the toast is browning without interrupting the cycle, where popping a normal toaster's lever ends it. It doesn't change the heating, though, so if a unit browns unevenly, checking mid-cycle won't fix that; it just lets you see it sooner.

Does it toast evenly?

Usually, once it has settled in. Bagels and bread can come out very even, but a new unit may toast unevenly for its first couple of dozen cycles before it becomes consistent, while others are even from the start. With 7 shade settings plus Bagel and Frozen functions, finding the right setting is easy; just expect a short calibration period rather than perfect toast on the first morning.

How much power does the toaster use, and what fits in the slots?

It has a 900-watt element and two extra-wide slots made for bagels and a wide variety of breads, and it measures 8.8 inches deep by 8.2 inches wide by 13 inches tall. The wide slots make it easy to get bread out without burning your fingers or shaking it loose.

Is this toaster reliable long-term, or does it fail early for some buyers?

This is the most important caveat. Durability is the toaster's weakest point, and several owners have had theirs stop working after about four months. It is not a universal problem, but it is frequent enough to take seriously, so buy from a retailer with a generous return window and keep the receipt.

What do the Bagel, Frozen, and Cancel functions actually do?

Oster says Bagel and Frozen automatically adjust the toasting time. Bagel browns the cut face while keeping the outside soft, and bagels are directional, so check the instructions for which way the cut side should face. Frozen lets bread go straight from the freezer into the slots. Cancel stops the cycle at the press of a button, useful if something starts smoking or you picked the wrong setting; it replaces the old habit of pulling up the lever, which may take some adjusting to.

Does this toaster look as good as the retro styling suggests?

Yes. The retro Impressions Collection look is its biggest strength: a textured blue finish on a stainless steel body with chrome accents. Colour is personal, so look closely at the shade before you buy, and note that it feels a little light in weight. The shell looks the part; just don't assume it guarantees the internals will last as long.

The Verdict

4.1Out of 5

The Oster Retro 2-Slice Toaster does the core job well: even toast across a wide shade range, a Bagel function that behaves as it should, and a quick-check lever that lets you look without stopping the cycle. The looks are its biggest draw. The drawbacks are real. A new unit may need about 20 uses before it toasts evenly, it is slow with frozen bread, there is no end-of-cycle bell, and the shade marker is hard to see. Durability is the bigger question, since some units have failed within a few months. For a small household that wants a toaster worth leaving on the counter it makes a sound case, bought somewhere with easy returns.

Who should buy it

  • Bagel eaters who want a proper Bagel function and wide slots
  • One- or two-person households who only need two slots
  • Buyers who want a toaster that looks good on the counter
  • Anyone who likes to check toast mid-cycle without stopping it

Buy it for even toast, a useful quick-check lever and the looks. If speed, an end-of-cycle alert or a clearly marked shade control matter most, this may not be the toaster for you.

Check price on Amazon

More Reviews

Nostalgia 3.5

Nostalgia Hot-Air Electric Popcorn Maker, 12 Cups, Healthy Oil Free Popc…

 AYOTEE 3.7

AYOTEE Wireless Mini Electric Food Processor and Garlic Chopper (100 ml,…

 OTOTO 4.3

OTOTO Fun Guy Mushroom Baking Soda Fridge Deodorizer Review